WASHINGTON, D.C. — Most Senate Democrats are publicly withholding support in the leadership fight between Chuck Schumer and challenger Chris Van Hollen, leaving the outcome uncertain ahead of the caucus’s Dec. 1 secret-ballot vote.
Only four members have publicly endorsed Van Hollen: Sens. Bernie Sanders and Jeff Merkley, along with Sens.-elect Abdul El-Sayed and Peggy Flanagan. Roughly 15 senators have publicly backed Schumer, still short of the approximately 30 votes needed to secure the leadership post.
Van Hollen says his private support is substantially stronger and argues some senators are reluctant to speak publicly because they fear retaliation from Schumer, who has led Senate Democrats since 2017.
“There is an element of concern about political retaliation,” Van Hollen told The Washington Sun. He also disputed reports suggesting Schumer has already secured enough support, saying some lawmakers listed as Schumer supporters have privately committed to him or remain undecided.
The contest has exposed competing interpretations of Democrats’ sweeping midterm victory. Schumer’s supporters credit him with candidate recruitment, fundraising and helping Democrats flip numerous Senate seats.
Others say the election reflected voter demand for broader political change and argue the party should not automatically return to its existing leadership.
Sen. Tim Kaine summarized the tension, praising Schumer’s work during the election while acknowledging voters were also “overwhelmingly demanding change.”
Several senators, including Cory Booker and Angela Alsobrooks, have declined to disclose their preference.
Because the election is conducted by secret ballot, the public may never know how every Democratic senator ultimately votes.
Sources: