New York judge strikes down state’s new redistricting maps in loss for Democrats

A state judge on Thursday struck New York’s new maps for congressional, state Senate and Assembly seats, calling them an example of unconstitutional “gerrymandering.”

Judge Patrick F. McAllister, an acting state Supreme Court justice in Steuben County, in central New York, ordered the Legislature to draw new maps — “that receive sufficient bipartisan support” — by April 11. New York is holding primary elections June 28.

He wrote in his ruling that the “process used” by state Democrats “to enact the 2022 redistricting maps was unconstitutional.”

Specifically, McAllister wrote that state Democrats ignored provisions of a 2014 constitutional amendment designed to prevent drawing partisan districts that govern the way the Legislature must consider maps drawn by a bipartisan commission.

If lawmakers fail to meet the April 11 deadline, “the court will retain a neutral expert at State expense to prepare said maps,” McAllister wrote. He added that legislators could move the state’s primaries to as late as Aug. 23 if it were to become necessary to delay them if maps weren’t agreed upon quickly.

That idea represents a reversal from one he’d made earlier this month, in which he’d written that there wasn’t enough time before the next elections to draw new maps.

Mike Murphy, the communications director for state Senate Democrats, tweeted Thursday that state Democrats would appeal the decision.

“This is one step in the process. We always knew this case would be decided by the appellate courts. We are appealing this decision and expect this decision will be stayed as the appeal process proceeds,” he tweeted.